Board index Barbecue Board Ask Steven Brisket


Do you have burning questions that need to be answered? A live-fire dilemma that needs to be solved? There are no secrets between grill masters. So I give you “Ask Steven,” a new forum, where you can ask me anything about food and flame. Post your questions here, and I’ll respond as quickly as I can, though at times, because I’m traveling around Planet Barbecue (and you can ask me about these adventures too), it might take me a couple of days to reply.
Post Thu Jan 09, 2014 10:41 pm
Wolfpackbbq well done
well done

Posts: 2671
Location: San Ramon, CA
Hi Steven,

This years goal is to focus on brisket. I have seen you mention parchment paper and cardboard lately in articles on BBQ joints you have visited. Can you expand on how these products are being used, but also what advantages they give the home quer. My last brisket came out good, but I want to strive for "Franklins" quality at home. I had the pleasure of eating there in September 2012 and had a nice chat with Aaron while he was filling my order. Well worth the 2+ hour wait. I just don't see a return trip to Austin soon and need to fill my brisket void with a brisket that I can get right consistently.


Post Wed Jan 15, 2014 9:40 pm
Steven Grilling Guru
Grilling Guru

Posts: 383

Dear Eric.

Sorry for the tardy reply. They've got me working overtime correcting the page proofs of my next book, Man Made Meals. I just now came up for air.

We're all trying to up our game with brisket. The most valuable technique I learned in 2013 was wrapping the meat in butcher paper. Depending on when you do it, wrapping has a host of benefits: holding in juices, keeping the brisket from drying out, even sealing in steam, which helps break down tough meat fibers.

In my travels in 2013, I watch people wrap foil, plastic wrap, and butchers paper. The foil is best at sealing in steam, which gives you a tender brisket--but one that has what Aaron Franklin (Austin pit master supremo) calls a "pot roasty" texture. (He does not mean it as a compliment.)

Franklin uses butcher paper on the theory that it lets the brisket "breathe." (It also facilitates moving the huge number of briskets he smokes each day.) He wraps about 2 hours before the brisket is done. As the grease soaks the paper through, it breathes less and creates a tighter seal. Also, it looks way cooler than foil.

I tried it recently on a grass-fed brisket from Whole Foods. Grass-fed briskets are notorious for toughening up and drying out, but this one came out as moist, fatty, and luscious as any brisket I've ever made. Wife was happy, because she prefers organic grass-fed beef. I was happy because, when wife is happy, guy is happy, but surely you know that already.

The trick is to find real butcher paper--coarse, porous paper--not the new fangled plastic-coated "paper" you find at upscale markets. This proved harder than it seems (go to a real butcher shop), but the results are worth it.

I learned th cardboard trick from Billy Durney at Hometown BBQ in Brooklyn. (I did a blog on Hometown a few weeks ago.) I'm speaking again with Billy next week, so I'll give you an update.

I regard brisket as a lifelong quest and journey. Here are some other techniques I've found useful. ... tc0paU5vwI

Thanks again for asking and for your patience, Eric.

Keep the questions coming, folks. It's one of the best parts of my job.


Post Thu Jan 16, 2014 1:59 pm
ScreamingChicken BBQ Deputy
BBQ Deputy

Posts: 8648
Location: Stoughton, WI
That's an interesting technique and I wonder how well it would work with a pork butt. I only foil after it's completely done but might give it a try.

Hobby stores like Hobby Lobby might have something similar to butcher paper. What about using a brown paper grocery bag? Are the texture and porosity similar?

Post Thu Feb 13, 2014 3:07 am

Posts: 4
Location: Terre Haute, Indiana
I wonder in Lieu of Butcher Paper, wich may be hard to find for some, and old style brown paper bag? hmmmmmm
“Mistakes come from lack of experience, unfortunately experience comes from making mistakes”_the Wockhunter

Return to Ask Steven